Noise adds to locals' woes

26/Sep/2012

Comments: 4 readers have left a comment

Local residents Ben Palmer, Lorna Hoogland and Barry Bailey. Local residents Ben Palmer, Lorna Hoogland and Barry Bailey.

LEEMING residents’ decade long battle with the Southern Metropolitan Council’s waste composting facility has reached frustrating new heights, with the plant now producing noise above permitted levels.

The Canning Vale plant’s licence was revoked by the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC) in March due to ongoing odour complaints, but was allowed to reopen in May.

High intensity fans introduced to address the odour are thought to be behind the latest complaints.

Earlier this month, Jandakot MLA Joe Francis told State Parliament he had received more than 130 emails relating to the SMRC since March.

“Residents have to put up with not only the smell from this plant but also now the noise – a constant hum at a constant frequency 24 hours a day, seven days a week,” he said.

Ben Palmer, of Sellen Court, said the noise delayed him getting to sleep and was sometimes loud enough to wake him up.

Environment Minister Bill Marmion said the DEC had identified noise levels exceeded permitted levels and had required the SMRC to take action to address the issue.

“The SMRC has advised it would endeavour to ensure it met acceptable noise levels by September 21,” he said.

“DEC will take further noise readings in the residential area after the noise attenuation works have been completed (and) the results of those readings will be considered as part of any enforcement action.”

Barry Bailey, of Atkinson Gardens, said the SMRC had been given enough chances.

“It’s the middle of suburbia, there’s no place for it in a built-up area,” he said.

Mr Francis said SMRC had no credibility with the community.

“They are continually over promising and under delivering,” he said.

Mr Francis said if issues were not resolved by December 15, SMRC had agreed to shut the plant down.


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Rod

30/01/2013

The SMRC has been a classic example of how easily people can be duped. I do not advocate landfill but for the supporters of the SMRC that have not taken the time to examine the facts, I would like to provide a few facts. The residents were here first, the SMRC promised there would be no odour issue, the SMRC requires at least 3 freight trips for each tonne of waste the WCF receives compared to one for landfill, it uses over$1.5 million in electricity per year, 50% of what it receives goes to landfill because it cannot be composted, its gatefees are about 80% higher than landfill, the compost does not have a market and is freighted to Brookton.
The Rockingham landfill saves more greenhouse gas per year than the SMRC, a similar plant owned by the MRC use 1 ton of water to process each ton of waste. In summary, the SMRC is costing the member councils ratepayer an addtional $10 million dollars a year to produce a compost it pays a contractor to cart away as it compost is "rubbish"

Nicole Issel

20/12/2012

Anyone who thinks shutting this place down is the answer is seriously uninformed.
It is not a toxic plant. However it does arrange for the proper disposal of toxic substances binned by the community.
Strange that all complaints seem to revolve around the compost facility which is not a threat to human health but prevents further damage. Anyone who knows the process of making compost knows that when done properly it kills all harmful bacteria and breaks down product into a usable natural fertilizer for plants. So our rubbish is not ending up in landfill where it can contaminate the air and water for years to come but being naturally treated and used to improve depleted soil.
People complain about compost smell so they create a state of the art fanned filtration system and are then stabbed again? Perhaps those who complain should be made to deal with their own waste. No collection service to those not wishing this place to process their waste.

Emily

04/10/2012

This is so ridiculous! The SMRC runs a state of the art facility providing a valuable and essential service for the south metro regional community. Help them make it better, don't bully them into shutting down, because they are actually doing something worthwhile. Where does our waste go when the SMRC composting facility shuts down? To landfill - a totally unsustainable way to treat our waste! Landfill is not the answer but people seem not to care as long as they don't have to see, hear or smell their waste.

garry stirling

27/09/2012

The residents have suffered enough!!!, from SMRC toxic plant !
when you read all their serious health problems, they have endured over years from this toxic plant . its time DEC and Ministers and other MPs final closed this plant for good!!! If This plant was in one of top UNCEH countries of the world ,its would have been closed years ago!!!

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Sunday 26 May 2013

  • Min 11°C
  • Max 24°C

Monday

  • 13 - 22°C

Tuesday

  • 12 - 21°C

Featured Video Clips

Subiaco's Cinemas Project

Western Suburbs Weekly reporter Erienne Lette and City of Subiaco Mayor Heather Henderson talks about the new Cinemas Project.

Oliver Hill Gun Battery

Editor Denise Cahill talks with Harriet Wyatt about new conservation and restoration works being done to the Oliver Hill Battery.

Cat Haven Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Erienne Lette with this week's Cat Haven update.

Dog Refuge Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Erienne Lette with this week's Dog Refuge update.

email subscribe link
CommunityPix banner linkCarbonFootie